Top 7 Commercial Real Estate Insurance Misconceptions

Top 7 Commercial Real Estate Insurance Misconceptions

These are the top 7 commercial real estate insurance misconceptions. Commercial insurance is becoming an increasingly relevant topic of conversation with individuals and organizations involved in the real estate industry. Gone are the days of insurance being a last-minute, easy task to accomplish before a closing transpires. Furthermore, insurance companies no longer engage in bidding wars to win business through the lowest premium. The insurance market is in a hardened state, particularly around property coverage. And the evidence suggests this isn’t necessarily a quick trend, but rather our new reality.

What made the list?

Our suggestion to clients with real estate holdings is to focus on controlling what they can control (the insurance market is not one of those things). Among a list of areas they have leverage, one of particular focus is tenant insurance verification. While this process can prove significant in securing the best offering for yourself as a real estate owner, we know it comes with challenges, complexities, and misconceptions in determining if your tenant is properly assuming the risk you transfer to them.

In today’s blog, we discuss the top seven commercial real estate insurance misconceptions. You can also watch our previously recorded webinar, 7 Insurance Misconceptions for Commercial Building Owners.

Misconception #1: All commercial insurance is the same.

The reality is insurance policies are legal contracts. While the Insurance Services Office (ISO) does provide forms that are utilized among different carriers, it is almost certain that one insurance policy to another will read differently in some (if not many) capacities. They have different forms, additions, endorsements, and terms. In reviewing your specific policy, it is best to understand a few of the most common definitions.

Common Definitions

  • Insured: The Individual, organization, or entity that is covered by the insurance policy.
  • Additional Insured: An entity or person added to the policy who also has benefits from coverage under the policy.
  • Waiver of Subrogation: The legal waiver of an insurer’s right to recover from damages paid in the insurance contract.
  • Primary and Non-Contributory: Clauses in insurance contracts that specify the order of which insurance policy will respond first, and what level of contribution each is obligated to.
  • Certificate of Insurance: A document provided to requesting parties that outlines key policy details and proof of insurance at the time of issuance.
  • General Liability: Coverage for an entity’s liability arising from its premise, operations, products, and completed operations.

These are just a handful of the definitions you may see in a commercial insurance policy. It’s always best practice to speak with your insurance provider to ensure the policies in place are in your best interest.

Misconception #2: You don’t need to read and understand your policy

Insurance policies can be hundreds of pages long. They’re lengthy, technical, and very dry. Of course, as a commercial real estate owner, you don’t have enough hours in the day to achieve all the relevant and important things, including reading your insurance policies from cover to cover. To make the most of policy reviews, it’s crucial to comprehend the overall structure of policies. This way, you can carefully examine all the sections that you consider important as soon as they’re released.


An easy way to read and understand a commercial insurance policy structure is through the acronym DICE, which stands for “Declarations, Insuring Agreements, Conditions and Exclusions.” 

  • Declarations: Typically the high-level overview of what exists within the policy. This will typically show the locations, assets, limits, etc. This is also the place where the premium outlays are shown.
  • Insuring Agreements: This is the legal language that states how coverage is triggered and what the insurer is agreeing to insure. This is essentially where the insurance company states, “You pay us a premium, this is what we’re covering.”
  • Conditions: This outlines the obligations of parties in the agreement. This section breaks down the things that owners are required to do or comply with in order to make sure that the insurance coverage is applicable. It also states the things that the insurance company is going to do on the owner’s behalf.
  • Exclusions: These are the things that the insurance company is stating outwardly that they are not covering.

Joe Vens, Risk Advisor at First MainStreet Insurance, tells his customers to read their policy back to front.

“I think it is beneficial to start with what the insurance company is outwardly telling you they are not covering, and then work your way back into the insuring agreements to see what still exists after the exclusions.”

Joe Vens, Risk Advisor at First MainStreet Insurance

People buy insurance because they want it to respond properly. By working on the front end and comprehending the policy, you can alleviate anxiety about potential coverage in the event of an insurance-related incident.

Misconception #3: Every Certificate of Insurance is the same

It’s important first to understand what a Certificate of Insurance is. A COI or certificate of insurance summarizes the coverage that exists at the time of issuance. An important note is that the COI is not an insurance policy itself. You can learn more about COIs by reading our articles What Is a Certificate of Insurance? and The Ins and Outs of Certificates of Insurance (COI).

Parts of a COI

COI Example.jpg
  1. Producer: The agency that is sending out the certificate.
  2. Insured: The person or organization that is insured. For purposes of this article, this would be the tenant who is verifying coverage to their landlord.
  3. List of Insurers: This is the list of different insurance agencies that are actually providing the coverage.
  4. Coverages: List of various types of insurance, policy numbers, effective dates and limits.

In summary, you can use certificates of insurance as a verification vehicle. Always ensure tenants carry the appropriate coverage and policies, and that they list their landlord as an additional insured on their policy. Why? To ensure that the tenant’s insurance policy provides coverage for defending the landlord in case of a lawsuit that the tenant is responsible for.

Misconception #4: You can manage COIs on your own

The process of managing certificates of insurance can be challenging and is often one of the first things that slip through the cracks. If you’re an owner with one tenant, perhaps you can keep track of it yourself on a spreadsheet. However, if you’re an owner with a portfolio of multiple assets and tenants, it becomes overwhelming.


By leveraging proprietary machine learning algorithms, tenants can upload a copy of their COI and our system will populate the owner’s required policy information. Once in our system, we compare the lease requirement against the policy information and flag discrepancies.

Mac Stratafolio site pages COI.jpg

We send email alerts when tenant’s policies are coming up for renewal to the tenant, the owner, and the insurance broker. By taking out the guesswork, we make managing COIs a breeze.

Misconception #5: Tenants can elect their own coverage

Leases are the documents that dictate who is responsible for what insurance coverage. You can state who is responsible for insuring the interior contents of a building and determine the legal language required within liability policies to ensure proper protection for requesting parties with applicable coverage.

Commercial property owners should invest the time and energy upfront into what insurance agreements should be in their leases. We recommend working with your commercial insurance advisor, if specialized in reviewing these agreements, to structure the correct language in those lease agreements.

Misconception #6: Securing commercial insurance can be acquired easily

The insurance market is currently experiencing a hard phase, where insurance pricing and rates have increased while the capacity has decreased. Additionally, there are fewer carriers willing to provide insurance. It can be a lengthy process to obtain commercial insurance right now. How can commercial owners combat this?

Be proactive

It takes more than a day to secure insurance for a commercial building. It all depends on the age and the characteristics of your tenant makeup. Insurance agencies like First MainStreet Insurance and their insurance company partners can require anywhere from a week to months or longer to properly underwrite and place coverage.

Consider the makeup of your tenants. Are they a fireworks dealer or a shoe store? Because there are factors you may not even consider. We recommend speaking with your insurance agent early on and providing them with full transparency, so they can best support you.

Misconception #7: Property owners have no control over their insurance

Many commercial owners may think they have no control over pricing/terms/coverage. Especially given the hard market we sit in today. A total lack of control is simply not the case. Creating cash flow reports, maintaining financial health, and understanding building and tenant characteristics can lead to better rates and terms for commercial real estate owners.

Owners should prepare to offer their insurance advisor with insight, information, and complete transparency. So, the advisor can provide the best support in placing reasonably priced coverage that offers optimal protection.

Using STRATAFOLIO to track your assets’ location, age, square footage, vacancy, and occupancy, among other things, can help commercial property owners prepare for when they need this information.

STRATAFOLIO also tracks tenant information, certificates of insurance, rent rolls, cash flow, and so much more. Best of all, this information is exportable through dynamic reports. This makes it easy to send it right to your insurance agency. A well-prepared, organized, and sophisticated owner has a greater likelihood of lower rates and better terms. Check out our knowledge base article on How to Automate Your Certificates of Insurance (COI) to see how we can save time for you and your team through automation and artificial intelligence.


Use the seven misconceptions to educate yourself and your team. This way, if and when an insurance event occurs, you are properly prepared.

Reach out to STRATAFOLIO for a personalized demo to see how we can help with COIs and beyond. Be sure to contact Joe Vens at the contact information below for discussions on risk transfer, securing insurance coverage, and proper risk management within your real estate organization.

Joe Vens.jpg

Other blogs you may like


Table of Contents

Subscribe to Our Blog

Join thousands of commercial real estate professionals staying up-to-date with the latest best practices for the industry.


At least one Intuit QuickBooks connection is required to use STRATAFOLIO.

Take advantage of our affiliate discount for US and Canada.

Get your QBO discount today!

Commercial Real Estate Software for QuickBooks Users

Talk to an expert about the time-saving benefits of using the top-rated commercial real estate software designed specifically for owners and managers who use QuickBooks.